Lunchtime Discussion: It’s A Chromosome Thing

Should there be such wide gender gap?
Published 04/12/2009 at 12:04 by Gastos84
Related stories (more)
Lunchtime Discussion: Gaming Style [24]
Lunchtime Discussion: Move [27]
Lunchtime Discussion: Betas [31]

Although Bayonetta is generating hype and criticism, it is one of only a handful of games that feature a female in the leading role. In fact, when you look at video games in general, the male/female characters begin to take on a rather stereotypical pattern. Here’s a list of games with leading ladies that I can remember:

  • Tomb Raider
  • Heavenly Sword
  • Bayonetta
  • Resident Evil (some)
  • BloodRayne

5! Is that it? Now whilst I’m sure you’ll be able to name some more, it goes to show that females aren’t high on the list when it comes to video game leads. Of course there are other ladies within male-driven games such as Uncharted’s Elena & Chloe, Elika, Chun-Li, Princesses of various description and Tails (you’re all thinking it), but these are only used as a method of advancing the story from a male point of view. They seem to all fall into a certain category:

  • The love interest
  • The plot’s goal (Princess/Wife/Sister/Mum/Second Cousin are taken hostage; rescue them)
  • The ball-busting enemy
  • Traitor
  • Sidekick (who generally can’t do anything other than get in the way)
  • Eye-candy (for those who find CG ladies attractive)

If they are a leading lady like the 5 I listed above, then they all fall into another category: Skilled Killers. Why is that they all become gun or sword-weilding acrobats? Heavenly Sword is the only game on the list that I can think of that actually needs to be a woman; In order to fulfill the father’s disappointment and a seemingly incorrect prophecy, then it was a necessity.

On the flip side, why are the majority of male leads stereotyped? Eight times out of ten you are bound to play a soldier, explorer, assassin, warrior or policeman. Why? Why aren’t we getting more realistic male and female figures within games? This is one of the reasons that Heavy Rain appeals to me; its inclusion of some ‘ordinary’ yet captivating (from what I’ve seen) people. This, believe it or not, is seen as innovative and original.

There is of course the argument that the video game industry is dominated by men and therefore we get the testosterone fuelled content that we are used to, but would playing a female put you off a game? There was one hell of an uproar from ignorant bigots when The Ballad of Gay Tony was released due to the fact that (for the first time that I can recall) a game/DLC was focused around someone who was gay. Surely we live in a more liberal society that these type of things shouldn’t matter. As long as the game is of good enough quality, who cares whether you play a woman, and are women put off gaming because of the lack of choice over their character type?

Discuss!

Comments

Please note that all comments are the opinion of the individual author and not TheSixthAxis.

  1. I guess the others I can think of are Faith from Mirrors Edge and the lady from Beyond Good and Evil. These two are probably two of the less overtly sexual of the lot too!


    • Damn, Ninja’d on the Faith part (See comment below.)


  2. Unless it’s a joke, the title should say “Chromosome” not “Chromosone”.
    ————
    I agree that women should be more involved characters in games, as when they are, it really appeals to me, the fact that it isn’t some ripped 25 year old guy running around like rambo.
    I am also looking forward to Heavy Rain due to its diversity of characters, it will be interesting to see how that pans out.
    And, how could you forget Faith? (Mirror’s Edge).


    • Haha! Glad you spotted that. It was a joke but thinking about it, it’s an in-joke so I had best change it!

      Oh and I hated Mirror’s Edge. /HATED/ it!


      • Ah okay, haha.
        Really? I enjoyed ME.. was a nice change of pace. Something.. different, you know?
        Each to his own I guess :)


      • I’m with you on Mirror’s edge, while I admire the fact that it tried something new, the control method drove me up the wall.

        Noone’s mentioned Samus from Metroid yet.


      • Okay, Yes, I’ll give you that – the controls were rather rubbish.


  3. Final Fantasy X-2 and XIII both feature female leads, don’t they?


  4. My missus is put off less by the male-centric characterisation of video games than the design of games in general these days, she’s happy to play through the games on the Sega Megadrive collection or have a crack at Mario when I wheel my SNES out.
    I think the issue probably arises from the industry itself being very male dominated, admittedly I’m not working from any facts or figures but I’ve worked in development roles for the last 10 years and I’d say maybe 10% of my coleagues (at a puch) have been female. I’d be happy to play a game featuring a female, or for that matter, gay lead, as long as I enjoy the game.


  5. I think it also depends where you look. Most of these games are designed by men for men, so the characters tend to be highly macho or sexualised as it is percieved that is what men want.

    I would suggest looking beyond those games and looking for the games aimed at being for women or unisex, such as animal crossing, pokemon or The Sims where the user is given choice over the gender to play.

    The fact of the matter is the laaarge majority of ‘core games are played by men and made by men and unfortunatly that seems to mean muscle bound men with space suits and guns. Hopefully as time goes by games will expand more like the film industry and games will not be so obviously gender bias. (That said we still have chick-flicks and male frat movies…so maybe I am just wrong)


    • I think games like Mass Effect and Dragon Age let you as well right? Bioware all the way!


      • Yup, and Knights of the Old republic too.


      • True, but the women in those games still often end up being overly sexualised…..i am not a fan of bioware’s idea of “romance”


    • There’s quite a few games featuring musclebound men _not_ in spacesuits. Allegedly. I certainly havent been looking for such things.


  6. Saints row took the other route by allowing you to choose your gender and appearance. 


  7. I can’t say I’ve played it, but I’ll bet that Hannah Montana game features a female lead ;-)


  8. I think its more a problem of a male dominated world and its not limited to video games, the movie industry suffers from this too..  Most movies, especially action movies features males as the protagonist and the ones that dont, are mostly ‘chick flicks’..  Obviously, there are exceptions, just like there are in all industries, but in a male dominated world, most protagonists are male because that’s what your main market consists of.  


  9. I dont why you are bothering with this discussion Gastos, obviously no women will reply because they will be busy playing “My Shopping Boutique” on the DSi. Or shopping.


    • You are one of very few people who can say this without it crossing my mind that it’s actually mean in offence.


    • or they’ll be trying the yoga on Wii Fit . . . or trying some brain training . . . or falling in love with Little Big PLanet


  10. Its pretty much the same in any film or book. Unless it was written by a women. Shame really. Oh and there’s ruby from WET


    • Female film directors are rather thin on the ground too, despite there being some rather talented ones out there, Gale Anne Hurd and Gurinder Chandha spring to mind, Nora Ephron most certainly does not.


  11. What about Dead or Alive Xtreme Beach Volleyball? If that isn’t a game based around girly girls doing girly girl things in a girly girl way, I don’t know what is :p
    Of course, they’re all stone cold man pulverising she-b*tches from hell when you see them at work, but DOAX showed them in their time out from that.

    It’s difficult for me to explain my thoughts on this matter. I just feel that a lot of times a female lead wouldn’t work, just like you won’t find many sensitive male leads who express their emotions well in the breaks between slaughtering hundreds of [insert enemy here].

    Female leads work a lot better when theres a complex storyline going on outside of the action genres in gaming. Games like Heavy Rain are trying to advance story telling in a way that will eventually be able to give us more lead characters of both genders that don’t have simple killing on their To Do list.

    But when it comes to action games, how are we meant to care about a character who doesn’t even speak, like so many games do? Part of the reason why we care about Nathan Drake is because of his strong characterisation in the cutscenes and his interactions with other NPCs. But as soon as you take the cutscenes out of the game, and the on the fly quips, it loses all of this and you’re left with some pretty graphics and gameplay as you slaughter hundreds of goons. Surely at that point it matters not what gender, species or planet the character comes from?

    So then it comes down to whether the game developers and story writers can craft a compelling storyline for whatever character they can come up with. With that in mind, war has always and will always be a largely male pursuit both in games and reality.


  12. There’s so many male leads in gaming because of the cycle of gamers and developers (all developers were gamers once… or at least 99% of them, surely). However, I’d have no problem with more female leads coming through but ultimately I’d just prefer to have an end to the cliched leads no matter the gender. I think that’s why Nate is so damned likeable from Uncharted 2. He’s not built like a brick sh**-house. Not overly handsome… has failings, quirks, sense of humour, personality, etc. Somethinig you rarely see in any male leads.


  13. I cant say its something i have paid an awful lot of attention to in the past, However i have been getting tired of these identikit male leads in games.
    How difficult is to create a character with a personality that you actually want to succeed?
    Uncharted is a perfect example of how characters should be done but most of the time i couldn’t care less whether the character lives or dies.
    I generally just get irritated with the game rather than feel any compassion towards whoever i am controlling.
    As for sidekicks … Most of them i certainly do want to see taken out (Zeke from inFamous among others)!
    As a side-note, There was a game i enjoyed on PS2 called Primal where the lead character was a female called Jennifer i think, If remember rightly though she may have been half-demon (Not sure if that qualifies).


  14. You can’t forget the woman from Portal. Thinking on it, there’s no real reason they made the lead a woman, I don’t think it would be to encourage women to play and she didn’t do anything a man couldn’t do?


    • for me it was the clever gameplay and the fact that it didn’t involve killing everything that moved that encouraged me to play.


  15. i think companies like bioware have the right idea, let the player choose the gender of the protagonist.
    i know there may be some occasions where the character has to have a set gender for the sake of the story but i don’t think there are many game plots where you couldn’t change the gender of the hero with just a few tweeks without affecting the overall storyline.
    like you said about heavenly sword, that was one of the few games where the gender of the character was an important plot point.
    would gta iv have been a very different game if we played as nicola bellic instead of niko? other than better driving :)
    it may not seem like it matters much but it can help you get into a game if you can identify with the protagonist a little.
    and bioware are one of the very few companies that recognise that not every gamer is straight.
    one of the great things about gaming is that it’s an interactive medium, ideally that would include the choice of a character you play that you can most identify with, or you think suits the story best.
    with a book or movie you don’t get to choose anything about the lead character.