XI
you are not logged in
Review

The Bureau: XCOM Declassified Review

[REDACTED]

Selling XCOM fans on the idea of a third person, cover based shooter hasn’t been an easy task for 2K. It has been apparent since the very first rumours of its existence that there would be some resistance to the idea. The occasional change to nomenclature or confused explanation (or understanding, at least) of the game’s purpose and aim haven’t helped matters at all.

The huge and, it appeared, somewhat surprising success of last year’s XCOM: Enemy Unknown (just Enemy Unknown from here on) might have unwittingly added to the struggles that 2K Marin faced in getting people to understand quite why they were sticking their development wands into this particular bubbling cauldron, just as that modernised branding became popular again.

So what’s the end result, a confused shooter that wears a strategy game’s name badge and pretends to know more than it does or a sublime step across genres which confounds the doubters and provides even more depth to the modern XCOM universe? You might be surprised.

The Bureau: XCOM Declassified (henceforth simply: The Bureau) owes its fiction and setting to its turn-based older brother, although this is something of a prequel – looking at how the fully fledged XCOM was born. In terms of gameplay inspiration, 2K Marin have obviously had to look elsewhere. The easy choice for developers in this genre is to mimic Gears of War fairly closely, tweaking what might better suit your fiction and retaining what has made Epic’s series so immensely playable.

But The Bureau isn’t a good fit for that kind of sweat-smeared, Bay-esque visual grandiloquence. A more subtle approach was needed and the result is a game that plays in quite a similar fashion to Mass Effect 3 (the numbering of that series is important for this kind of comparison).

That similarity persists in the way special abilities are used and selected in combat. The action is slowed to a crawl with a face button while you left-stick around a wheel that shows all available actions for you and your two team members. This ranges from movement between cover and instructions for the revival of fallen comrades to the full range of special abilities that can be used in conjunction with each other to make combat go more favourably. You might drop a laser turret with an engineer and then raise it up with your special alien tech vambrace so that it can see over the enemy’s cover. You might taunt an opponent to run from cover and use your recon squad mate’s critical hit ability to headshot him out of your immediate concern.

During combat, the movement as agile and light with a healthy sprint and snap-to-cover mechanic that never gets in the way. You’ll pop out of cover to aim and shoot, vault the multitudinous waist-height obstructions and navigate the combat arenas that make up the bulk of the entertainment to be had in the campaign. Enemy AI is reasonably smart too, flanking when it can, making use of its healers and rushing you when you’re starting to feel comfortable. Those combat arenas are linked by quite narrow corridors of terrain to navigate so it’s an entirely linear experience until you’re in the cover-strewn regions that obviously take their inspiration from Enemy Unknown’s maps.

Once you’re in those areas, though, the method of assault and defence is entirely up to you. You’ll have another two squad mates alongside you, each with their own abilities, equipment and experience levels. That’s the other aspect of The Bureau that takes its queues from Enemy Unknown: meaningful loss or, as the game itself puts it, combat with consequences. If one of your accompanying squad mates is gunned down in battle, you’ll have a brief window of opportunity to revive them (the higher the difficulty setting, the more brief the window). If you miss that opportunity, they bleed out, die and are lost forever. So you could have an engineer levelled up to a respectable state, encounter stiff opposition and lose him – and all of his talents – forever. If you lose all of your agents, you lose the game.

You’re encouraged to keep a fully stocked roster of agents with which to populate your in-mission team and it makes sense to try to keep them all levelled up as much as possible. On easier difficulty settings, you can switch them out at certain resupply points along the mission path so one mission could gently level several of your compatriots. On tougher settings, that luxury is removed and you’ll, sensibly, only be able to change your team from the XCOM home base.

Keeping well levelled agents is not just beneficial in you own team selection for playable missions, you can also send them out on their own. These Dispatch Missions require a certain collective ability so they might need a level of 10 but you could send two level 5 agents to complete the mission. They come with the potential risk of losing an agent but they also yield new technology and assistance in the form of personnel to work on the home base.

Base building was another key strategic element in Enemy Unknown that has bled slightly into The Bureau. It’s certainly not as deep or as integral to the success of a mission – more a tool of the narrative – but between missions you’ll wander around the clandestine complex, picking up hints and gathering new direction from various personnel you encounter.

The conversations you have can offer pertinent information for later missions or simply offer cute little diversions as you come to know the people around you. Again, the conversation selection tool is reminiscent of Mass Effect, with a wheel to select your responses as you interact with others and probe for information down branching conversation paths. It’s not exactly deep but it does offer a more thoughtful aspect to the action – tying up back stories and motivations – than most other third person shooters can be bothered to muster.

The atmosphere makes The Bureau truly unique. While most sci-fi shooters stretch for futuristic industrialism or fantastical alien settings, The Bureau is set very much in a horn-rimmed, nicotine-stained 1962 that feels oddly familiar while allowing enough alien technology and presence that the rigidity and starched shirts of the burgeoning anti-Soviet military-industrial complex has a colourful foil against which to juxtapose.

The music plays a big part in this, its sinister tones and light-hearted pizzicato melodies recalling similar pieces from other media in this genre and time setting. It’s beautifully mixed with some nice period references to really create an evocative, believable world in spite of the extraterrestrial influences. Even when the setting for the action does become a little more other-worldly at times, there’s a resilient strand of 1960s American DNA mutating to the fore.

What’s Good:

  • The atmosphere is perfectly of the period.
  • It manages to feel very much like XCOM without being anything like XCOM.
  • Combat is enjoyable and complex with smart AI.

What’s Bad:

  • Pacing feels a little laboured at times, particularly the base-bound sections.
  • Slightly rough around the edges in terms of animations and modelling.

The Bureau comes as a very pleasant surprise. It’s not a cynical cash-in on Enemy Unknown’s success, it’s not a forgettable me-too third person cover-based shooter and it’s not a clunky shoe-horning of familiar ideas into a new set of mechanics. The Bureau has occasional problems with pacing, it could do with a little more polish and it doesn’t revolutionise shooters but it does adroitly step sideways into a totally unfamiliar genre and it expands the greater fiction while doing so. Another successful XCOM mission.

Score: 8/10

14 Comments
  1. Airiaen
    Member
    Since: Aug 2009

    The review has made it more intriguing considering I’ve been unsure about it. however With Wonderful 101 released on the same day I’d probably have to hold out heh.

    Comment posted on 20/08/2013 at 05:08.
  2. tonycawley
    Pint! Pint!
    Since: Feb 2009

    Excellent, that was exactly what I wanted to hear. Think it’s a sale as far as I’m concerned. Good review again peter.

    Comment posted on 20/08/2013 at 06:32.
    • tonycawley
      Pint! Pint!
      Since: Feb 2009

      At this moment, this is the highest review score on metacritic. Everything else seems to be teetering around 6s. I read the ign review, they came up with a good point not touched upon here.
      If this happened in the 1960s, how come the xcom in 2010 were unaware of the aliens? Or was enemy unknown also set in the 60s?
      I think I’m being thick, I played through enemy unknown but don’t remember the year it was set!
      It is meant to be a prequel though, so the question remains regardless. If this all happened before, why is earth so surprised in enemy unknown about the alien invasion?

      Comment posted on 20/08/2013 at 07:00.
      • BryOnRye
        Member
        Since: Jan 2009

        Enemy Unknown started in 2015.

        Comment posted on 20/08/2013 at 07:21.
      • Peter Chapman
        Team TSA: Editor
        Since: Forever

        I suppose it does kind of rewrite the history a bit as you’re playing it (as Enemy Unknown did after the original XCOM-based games) but I was always a little bit bothered by the fact that Aliens landed and all of a sudden there was a global, cooperating task force in place. I suppose if you kind of merge the two together a bit in your head, and ignore the fact that The Bureau already finds plenty of alien tech before Enemy Unknown begins, you’ll make yourself a decent emergence story.
        I think Enemy Unknown was set in the very near future. The original games were set in 1999, I think.

        Comment posted on 20/08/2013 at 07:21.
      • tonycawley
        Pint! Pint!
        Since: Feb 2009

        It does stink like they didn’t really think it through though doesn’t it? That’s never a good sign.
        Both reviews I’ve read now say the combat is decent, I know I love the universe so I’m in. I actually like the sound of the mass effect 3 comparisons too.

        Comment posted on 20/08/2013 at 07:46.
      • Peter Chapman
        Team TSA: Editor
        Since: Forever

        oh, I think it’s absolutely a case of:
        “we want to make a game about aliens set against the Cold War”
        “well, we own XCOM…”
        “Yeah, we can make that work!”

        but, if you’re willing to let the already pounded timelines in this series have plenty of leeway, it does work – mostly :)

        Comment posted on 20/08/2013 at 08:12.
      • cc_star
        Team TSA: Writer
        Since: Forever

        A suspension of disbelief is probably required, kinda how the whole of Avengers Assemble was extremely awkwardly glossed over in Iron Man 3 as “Aliens? Urgh… let’s never mention events in New York”

        Comment posted on 20/08/2013 at 08:13.
  3. BryOnRye
    Member
    Since: Jan 2009

    Good stuff, I’d expected this to be pretty awful so it’s a nice surprise. Only just finished enemy unknown too so perfect timing.

    Comment posted on 20/08/2013 at 07:22.
  4. RocketSOL
    Member
    Since: Oct 2008

    Good review. I’ll definitely be getting this, just a question of when. I still need to finish Enemy Unknown. Would you say this is just as unforgiving as Enemy Unknown? I’ve only played it on normal and I’ve lost 3 times!

    Comment posted on 20/08/2013 at 09:02.
  5. TSBonyman
    Member
    Since: Dec 2009

    Good review, i wasn’t sure about this until i watched some ps3 footage last night and it looks pretty good.

    Comment posted on 20/08/2013 at 10:21.
  6. Roynaldo
    Member
    Since: Nov 2008

    Nice review. Not sure about the game itself being my thing. Might pick it up sometime down the line.

    Well done cb.

    Comment posted on 20/08/2013 at 10:27.
  7. bunimomike
    Member
    Since: Jul 2009

    Not really interested in Enemy Unknown as the genre isn’t for me. This, however, has me sold. Love the era and when they weave aliens into it. :-)

    Comment posted on 20/08/2013 at 10:31.
    • yiddo
      Member
      Since: Jun 2010

      Same here. Never played an XCOM game, but the stylistic setting and look of this game appeals to me massively.

      It’s like Mad Men + Cold War + Aliens.

      Comment posted on 20/08/2013 at 17:05.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

The Bureau: XCOM Declassified
  • Developer:2K Marin
  • Publisher:2K Games
  • Platforms:PS3, X360, PC
  • Release Date:23/08/13
3

Latest Comments