XI
you are not logged in
Review

Red Dead Redemption 2 Review

Dead good.

“I wanna be a cowboy, baby” sang Kid Rock back in 1999. He never would be one of course, instead he just spent his time looking like he was wearing his dad’s clothes. Had Robert James Ritchie embarked upon his career in 2018, he would never needed to have sung about his western fuelled dreams, instead he could have just played Red Read Redemption 2. For those without easy access to a time a machine, Rockstar Games’ crowning achievement is the closest they will ever come to actually ‘being’ in the Wild West.

The world this legendary studio has created in RDR2 is one of the most atmospheric, breathtakingly detailed and terrifyingly expansive game environments I have ever inhabited. Expectations are understandably sky-high for this sequel to the 2010 classic, but if Rockstar were under pressure to deliver on their grandstanding they certainly haven’t shown it, RDR2 almost effortlessly delivers on its many promises.

Taking on the role of Arthur Morgan, a magnificently charismatic member of the Van der Linde gang, the game immediately throws the player into the thick of it. Freezing, near-broken and disarrayed atop a snow-swept mountain, the gang are on the run from the repercussions of a mysterious heist that went badly wrong.

Rockstar seamlessly introduce the members of the gang over the next hour. Whilst each of them is an individual, brought to life by some outstanding voiceover work, they are also part of a collective; the player’s family. They form the foundation that RDR2 is based around, not only giving the player missions but also their motivation. Your over-arching objective is to protect your gang, your family by any means necessary.

It is these missions that, as you would expect, provide the backbone of the RDR2 experience. They are amongst the best that Rockstar have ever crafted and a significant step up from the last game in the series. The tasks you undertake introduce the varied elements of the game, but more importantly provide ample opportunity to form bonds with your gang.

The most effective missions are often those that involve no combat at all; getting drunk with a protégé at the local town’s bar, teaching John Marston’s son how to fish (no more spoiler’s on how the previous game’s protagonist is integrated into the narrative, but suffice to say it’s brilliantly handled), or having a heart to heart with Arthur’s mentor and father figure – Dutch van der Linde – as you both ride across the great plains. It is taking the time for these more peaceful character moments that make the emotional gut punches further into the story so powerful.  You genuinely care about your gang and what happens to them, aligning you with Arthur’s motivation to keep everyone safe and buy them a future.

How you go about this, outside of the main narrative, is up to you. Hold up any shopkeeper, perform train heists, steal stage coaches, hunt a vast array of animals for their valuable hides – the entire game world, once the short snow-covered prologue is complete, is yours to explore. However, in certain states you begin the game wanted Dead or Alive, making successful exploration without a bounty hunter’s bullet between your eyes rather tricky. The game world is vast and there will be many lengthy expeditions on your horse required to see it all. Often the game runs the risks of these journey’s being too long, of taking too much time to get from A to B and then back to A again. Fortunately Rockstar has two cunning tricks up their virtual sleeves to keep the player engaged during these moments.

Firstly, the game world is breathtakingly beautiful. When it comes to environmental detail, RDR2 is a significant improvement on every game that has come before it. The sun glistens through leaves, casting the shadows of the leafy canopy onto the earth below – the dappled shade even moves across the forms of your posse as you ride through woodland. Climb a peak and the entire world spreads out beneath you, I found myself spending a full ten minutes just watching the weather change despite the fact that I had a looming deadline approaching. Visually this game is simply jaw-dropping. And the snow, by Zeus’s fuzzy soup strainer, looks better than real snow. Every time you begin another epic ride across the world, your eyeballs will be in for a treat.

Secondly, the world lives and breathes like no other. Gone is the trope of many open-world games that has NPCs remaining silent and stationary with a question mark above their heads until you interact with them. Instead, NPCs have their own agency and feel much more alive for it. As you go about your business, events occur around you and you can choose to engage with them or not. Prisoners being transported call out for rescue, a trapper needs to be saved from his own bear trap, a member of your gang will find you and ask your help to carry out an impromptu rescue, you’ll even have other criminals from rival gangs try to hold you up or assassinate you – which they usually end up regretting.

The weaponry available to you, despite being antique, is wonderfully satisfying to use. The guns have real weight, heft and sense of recoil, with a kinetic power that cannot fail to excite. Shotguns see your foes punched through the air, sniper rifles slap into a far-away henchman’s head, causing it snap back with ferocious force, occasionally triggering a close up kill cam. Then there are the tomahawks; if there’s a more enjoyable weapon to use in video games then I’ll be shocked.

It’s a shame then, that most encounters devolve into the player hiding behind cover while hordes of enemies run towards their position to get shot. Little more is required of you than doing an ‘Arnie in Commando’. Your foes don’t even attempt to flank you, though they will seek cover, not that it does them much good thanks to Arthur’s all-powerful auto-aim and Dead Eye to slow time. The effect of this is to make you feel like an absolute bad-ass, the down-side is that most shoot-outs are a breeze.

Fisticuffs are also borderline forgettable. Your enemies wait in an orderly fashion to get punched in the face, circling around you politely until you deal with their buddy. It’s a little underwhelming but serves its purpose. Fortunately, despite the weaker elements to the combat, the sheer majesty of the overall experience made any issues with it fade into the background.

Amongst all of this action though, you’ll have to spend time maintaining the health of Arthur and his horse. You’ll need to wash, eat, and rest and you’ll also need to brush, feed and give your horse time to chill out. Failing to do these things will have a detrimental effect on both you and your equine pal’s stamina and health – and given that your horse won’t come back from dying, that’s a bad thing. You’ll even need to make sure you’re wearing the correct clothing for the weather or climate of the area you are in, as well as oiling and maintaining your weapons.

If this all sounds a little too much like busy work then you’d be right. The micro-management required of you can occasionally drag, but on the flip side it offers you a phenomenal amount of scope to customise your character’s appearance. Every item of clothing can be altered, every weapon can be upgraded with scopes, rifling and an assortment of hand grips. You can even plait your horse’s tail. Oh, and Rockstar’s boast about horse’s testicles? It’s totally true. I spent several hours of traumatic exploration in first person view to research it. My horse, Barry, was not impressed.

What’s Good:

  • Incredibly engaging game world
  • Compelling characters that you will actually care about
  • Some of the best visuals of all time
  • Tomahawks should now be in every game

What’s Bad:

  • Fisticuffs are underwhelming
  • Shoot-outs are a little one note
  • Busy work verges on being too much like work

The hype being created for Red Dead Redemption 2 and the expectations of the passionate fan-base made a part of me believe that Rockstar Games could never deliver on all of their many promises. They did, and then some. From the feeling of a realistic living world they’ve created to the emotional bonds you build, Red Dead Redemption 2 is the video game experience of this generation.

Score: 10/10

Version Tested: PlayStation 4

Also available on Xbox One

23 Comments
  1. tonyyeb
    Member
    Since: Aug 2010

    “Busy work verges on being too much like work” – This is what concerned me when the first gameplay trailers came out. Just like in the GTA games, it became a chore to do the side stuff, socialising with friends etc.

    Comment posted on 25/10/2018 at 12:04.
    • Adrian Burrows
      Member
      Since: Jul 2017

      Yeah, the busy work can occasionally drag. You can get away with doing the basics however; having something to eat and looking after your weapons and horse is sufficient.

      Comment posted on 25/10/2018 at 12:12.
      • tonyyeb
        Member
        Since: Aug 2010

        Good, I really don’t have the time to do stuff like that!

        Comment posted on 25/10/2018 at 12:14.
      • Adrian Burrows
        Member
        Since: Jul 2017

        Top tip: give Arthur the ‘spartan’ facial hair style. It looks great at any length and so requires zero maintenance.

        Comment posted on 25/10/2018 at 12:16.
  2. bennibop
    Member
    Since: Aug 2014

    Fisticuffs are underwhelming
    Shoot-outs are a little one note
    Busy work verges on being too much like work

    And you gave the game a 10? These don’t seem like minor gripes, these are core aspects of the gameplay!

    Comment posted on 25/10/2018 at 12:33.
    • Adrian Burrows
      Member
      Since: Jul 2017

      Normally I’d totally agree with you but within the overall scope and vision of the game they didn’t end up feeling like a big deal to me. It is one of those games where you end up having these individual experiences that lead to great stories to tell your mates about.

      Comment posted on 25/10/2018 at 12:55.
    • Eldave0
      andUandU
      Since: Aug 2008

      I picked up on that too. The review itself (obviously) explains things better but those bullet points suggest “yeah its an amazing game, except the actual gameplay”.

      Comment posted on 25/10/2018 at 12:56.
      • bennibop
        Member
        Since: Aug 2014

        It’s alarm bells for me, I think the last rdr was over rated (thought it was good not great) but similar issue existed back then – World great gameplay average.

        Comment posted on 25/10/2018 at 13:03.
    • JR.
      Member
      Since: Apr 2013

      I’ve always had these issues with R* games. Very clunky gameplay. I’m sure I’ll still enjoy this but R* games always score 10/10 across the board and are always massively overrated IMO.

      Comment posted on 25/10/2018 at 15:27.
  3. ron_mcphatty
    Member
    Since: Sep 2008

    Excellent review, it’s gotten me even more excited for tomorrow. It’s good to hear that Rockstar have nailed the immersion once again, their worlds are just so beautifully crafted that for them not to set a new bar would be very (possibly unfairly) disappointing. But to read about a rich world with endearing characters, beautiful landscapes and fun action is a magnificent thing! My JM’s horse José got shot in a botched robbery back in RDR, I look forward to checking out the gonads that produced him and giving his old man, who I’ll name Seniore José, a good hard ride. Yeehaw!

    Comment posted on 25/10/2018 at 12:35.
  4. MrYd
    Member
    Since: Mar 2011

    So have they managed to have a game and it’s sequel be the best game on 2 generations of consoles in a row then?

    And how long does it take to install from disc then? Or did you get a digital copy for review?

    Comment posted on 25/10/2018 at 12:48.
    • Adrian Burrows
      Member
      Since: Jul 2017

      I’d say so.

      It was a digital copy. About 94 gig in the end as I recall. So, it took a loooong time. Worth the wait though!

      Comment posted on 25/10/2018 at 12:52.
      • MrYd
        Member
        Since: Mar 2011

        So, probably about 8.5 hours to download if your PS4 is using WiFi. It struggles to get much above 25Mbit/s that way.

        Did it let you start playing before the download was finished?

        I’ll get it on disc, but that’s still going to take a couple of hours to install.

        Technically I should wait for my birthday, but that’s 8 days after it’s released, so bollocks to that. Big weather-affected horse bollocks to that.

        Comment posted on 25/10/2018 at 13:00.
      • double-o-dave
        Member
        Since: Nov 2008

        I just bought it at online whilst at work, tried to download it but said waiting & just discovered it’s because I hadn’t updated my PS4 system. Sneaked out the office, biked home at sonic speed, updated the system, started the download, biked back to work and sneaked back in the office.

        I get about 27Mbit/s and it says 6 hours.

        More worrying is no one noticed I went missing for the best part of an hour.

        Comment posted on 25/10/2018 at 15:50.
      • Pixel_nme
        Member
        Since: Mar 2014

        Took just under 3hrs on our 80Meg wired connection.

        Comment posted on 25/10/2018 at 16:43.
      • MrYd
        Member
        Since: Mar 2011

        So based on the progress so far, it was going to take a couple of hours to install from the discs, but it’s probably going to end up being about 90 minutes. Initial estimates of the time remaining are never very accurate.

        Comment posted on 26/10/2018 at 10:38.
  5. Foxhound_Solid
    Is a smart cookie.
    Since: Dec 2009

    All over this. Cracking review as always!!

    Why cant time speed the hell up. I need this game.

    What in tarnation, its still Thursday, damn it!!??

    Comment posted on 25/10/2018 at 13:07.
    • ron_mcphatty
      Member
      Since: Sep 2008

      *Closes eyes, sleeps, opens eyes, checks phone* Bollocks, still Thursday!!

      Comment posted on 25/10/2018 at 13:23.
      • Foxhound_Solid
        Is a smart cookie.
        Since: Dec 2009

        Damn Thursday to hell!

        Comment posted on 25/10/2018 at 15:27.
      • ron_mcphatty
        Member
        Since: Sep 2008

        Yeah! Bloody Thursday! Which was it original, F5 Tuesday or Thursday? Thursday is a load of arse.

        Comment posted on 25/10/2018 at 16:19.
  6. Andrewww
    Member
    Since: Jan 2010

    I have to admit it’s quite difficult not to be hyped by everybody going crazy about this game, but I read the review and remain calm and think I’ll get it sometime later in a sale.

    Comment posted on 26/10/2018 at 07:37.
  7. Dominic Leighton
    Member
    Since: Mar 2012

    I am forcing myself to finally finish the first game if I’m to be allowed to buy this. Which probably means I’ll never actually get it.

    Comment posted on 26/10/2018 at 08:58.
    • Adrian Burrows
      Member
      Since: Jul 2017

      But with this being a prequel, from a narrative perspective, you should go play RDR2 first!

      Comment posted on 26/10/2018 at 10:51.