Survival action masterpiece, The Last Of Us, is a beauty of a game to behold. Behind its nail-baiting gameplay and compelling story is a level of detail that few games will ever match on current-gen hardware. However, Naughty Dog’s pursuit in sculpting this authentic, believable setting could lead to a potential copyright lawsuit.
Twitter user, Neo781, recently highlighted just how accurately the developer had recreated a transport map found during one of the game’s early stages.
Wow they actually accurately portray the subway map of Mass and have all the colors and names of stops correct. pic.twitter.com/ovIG3ncqCr
— Kelvin (@Neo781) June 22, 2013
The map in question looks strikingly similar, if not identical, to that of designer Cameron Booth, who posted the original on his blog back in 2012:
“Basically, I’m fucking furious,” tells Booth in a recent post. He claims that the map was used in The Last Of Us without notice or consent:
For a software developer — especially a big developer working on a blockbuster title like this — to casually appropriate someone else’s work and incorporate it into their game without any discussion with the owner of that work is completely unacceptable.
Unfortunately we don’t have an expert on American copyright law to hand but, in general terms, using someone else’s work in your own creation is deemed unlawful if the originator is not duly credited, especially in commercial products.
I am attempting to open communications with them now to ask where they came across the image, how it ended up in their game (with very pointed questions about their approvals and legal process), and what kind of compensation I can expect for the theft of my work.
If Naughty Dog are unable to prove that the map is its own original work, chances are, Mr. Booth can expect an apology a fair amount of compensation.

YOURMUMANDME
I’ve checked through the feed and apparently Naughty Dog have released a statement saying that they made their own copy and it took a staff member 60-80 hours to make. Which would make sense as Cameron Booth has now closed the comments on Disqus, conveniently leaving a lot of negative feedback for the public eye.
ron_mcphatty
Good old ND, 60+ hours on a map for a texture is a cracking level of effort and attention to detail.
Jakster123x
Damn, that’s unbelievable actually. Incredible attention to detail.
bunimomike
To be honest, I’d quote 8 to 10 hours to have that map recreated in a perfect vector format. 60 to 80 hours seems hilariously over the top. I’m a meticulous bugger with things like this too which means the time is used methodically but accurately. Someone’s telling porkies! (read: ND)
a inferior race
TBH if someone spent 80 hours on that they should be working on TLG.
double-o-dave
I’d say an afternoon’s work in Illustrator and most of that would be putting the bloody wording in.
Kennykazey
Now that sounds like BS, the only difference is some dirt. If they made their own copy, it shouldn’t look this similar.
Jakster123x
Yeah, I feel sort of stupid for believing that, but it turns out that Booth’s spoken to ND and they apologised and are sorting things out now.
YOURMUMANDME
As it turns out…..that information was tripe. Now I’ll apologise! :D
Fartinabag
Won’t get anything, as clearly he hasn’t lost anything, and it will be removed in the next patch.
Perhaps Naughty Dog could charge him for his 5 minutes of lame-ass “fame”.
JBoo
“Basically, I’m fucking furious,” BOOHOO LoL:D I would be flattered if they used any of my work in their game.
Porcupine_I
I am sure mister Booth has been paid for making this map and he was aware that it was intended for everyone to see for free?
or is he standing with a hat next to his maps collecting money from everyone who happens to take a look at it?
bunimomike
It’s about reproduction of the map not people viewing it. For example, when I buy clipart (to use in designs) I pay a pre-negotiated price to use a photo or illustration in any of my designs. I sign a contract and always try to abide by the usage guidelines stated.
I would be frustrated that they didn’t come to me first as I would let them use it for nothing but a client might’ve paid for it to be done (initially) so you also have to respect the fact that its usage might lie with the client and not even the designer. Depends what was set-up in the initial contract.
However, his initial reaction was ferociously over the top and he needs to calm down.
xdarkmagician
Alot of subways use colors to differentiate between rails, so the “Red Line” being red in both makes logical sense, as does the shapes of the individual lines as they’re both ment to represent the actually subway system. With that said, there are slight differences between the two maps, but the differences are that ND’s map has just omitted certain aspects, like the yellow lines. What remains is a near identical match, near identical mostly because the ND map is intentionally dirty and shaded. Under identical lighting conditions they would be completely identical.
If ND says that the map is original they’re lying their asses off (as long as Mr Booth did indeed create his map when he says he did). You cant work on creating a map for 60+ hours and have it appear identical to something someone else created. They obviously used a map for inspiration, clearly it was Booth’s design. And honestly 60-80 hours for designing a map is bullshit. First it would only take a few hours to draw a map like that, its just lines and names. Second, anybody trying to acutely duplicate a map would copy another map, it just logical. No video game designer is going to compile all the raw data, figure out scale, and design a copy when they’ve got google and photoshop. If I was ND I’d fire the person who put in 60- 80 hours on this as its obvious he copied and pasted the design, and then fucked-off for the next 2 weeks.
ND should pay, whether its Mr Booth, or the Mass subway, either way the unlawfully represented someone else’s work as their own. I’d say fair compensation, 60-80 hours of pay from the designer who copied it.
PriceofWar
If Naughty Dog put something I created in one of their games I’d be honored, especially in a game like The Last of Us.
Alex C
Some weird comments in this post. If ND ripped off someone’s work then that’s shit, no matter how good the game.
ron_mcphatty
I can see your point. I’d imagine you’d be fairly fucked off if someone reproduced your Unfinished Swan review and profited from the cleverness (I can’t remember now but did that actually happen, was it that Turkish site?), but then maps are a bit different. The transit map style has been around for a hundred years so this guy kicking up such a fuss is a bit of a piss take, it’s hardly his own design philosophy that’s been profited from. Having said that, if it was a 60 hour tracing job then it’s definitely a bit cheeky. Hmm, I’m not sure which side of this fence I want to sit in now.
Alex C
Nobody ripped off the US review, despite me detailing how I did it the next day. ;)
ron_mcphatty
Good to know. And I just had a look at that article, more of a tutorial I suppose, I understood very little but it was fascinating!
bunimomike
What really bothers me, Al, is if this hit the courts (over in the U.S.) the compensatory measures they use are hilarious. Forget reasonable recompense. The litigious society over there would have him down for a few million. That, I utterly detest.
Thankfully, it appears to have all calmed down.
Origami Killer
I completely agree with this, but I still stand by the comment I posted earlier about an overreaction. He hasn’t handled it in a very professional manner tbh.
Dazbobaby
isn’t the tube system run on public money in Mass? If so isn’t the information also part of the public domain? The map creator had to use public tube maps to create his own map. So maybe he’s plagiarised someone else to make it in the first place.
Still sounds like he’s being a prick.
Dazbobaby
on closer inspection it is very similar but far from identical.
2ofclubs
Might want to update the post gents. Cameron has spoke to ND:
UPDATE, TUESDAY JUNE 25, 1:00pm: I’ve just spoken with Naughty Dog over the phone in a very constructive conversation. Can’t say more at the moment, but it seems as if matters will be resolved to everyone’s satisfaction shortly. I can say that they do acknowledge their error in using my map and were very apologetic for it. I likewise apologised for my initial vitriolic post. A lot of mutual respect for each other’s creative work.
It’s been a hell of a last couple of days: thanks for the support from many, and the interesting and varied comments from most.
Hopefully, back to regularly scheduled Transit Maps content soon!
Alex C
So they admit it? Bizarre.
2ofclubs
Apparantly so. I doubt Cameron would make it up given his obvious fury so it surely must be true. Either that or ND accepting using it as inspiration rather that a direct copy. I guess that’s between them now.
bunimomike
They probably promised him a new Xbox One as compensation. He doesn’t realise the jokes on him. :P
Wozman23
I wasn’t going to buy The Last of Us. It didn’t look that good… but then I was like, “Damn, they got that Cameron Booth subway map in this game!”… Bought it Day 1!
An subway map based off of real life seems easy to reproduce closely without ill intent. It’s not like the artist from Borderlands 2 directly lifting the skyline from Olly Moss’ work.