Opinion: The Real Problem With PlayStation Minis

Questions and answers.

It’s not all about snapping quotes for headlines and ranting about Trophies; there’s a serious issue bubbling here that – mostly thanks to the actions of Velocity developer Futurlab – is just starting to get some mainstream attention. The more sites that pick up on the quality of some of the minis the better, but I personally think that the real issue is that we, as an industry, need to get Sony themselves to change their way of thinking a bit.

Pitchforks away, this isn’t a case of camping outside each region’s offices with placards and weak tea. The answer’s actually fairly straightforward: get everyone involved together, united, and the platform holder will have to listen. This started this morning with the brief survey about minis – a single survey that’s getting distributed as widely as possible by as many people that care.

The results won’t be surprising – gamers want trophies and they want multiplayer – two things that minis don’t provide. The restrictions set in place by SCE back when the service was originally coined were heavy and remain so, presumably as a result of the rampant piracy on the PSP which the minis were originally designed for but also to ensure that development was as simple, swift and – hopefully – bug free as possible.

Developers, generally, like dealing with Sony. That’s not insider sources or whispered secrets, it’s public knowledge. But at the other end of the spectrum the buying public seem to be either unaware of what minis are or – perhaps worse – unwilling to give them a fair shot because the other purchases they make on PS3 and PS Vita come with far more flexibility in terms of multiplayer and virtual silverware – the things that give the games added life.

Think about it: had MotorStorm RC released as a minis game, who would have bought it? There’d be no DLC (so no new level packs), no online leaderboards to battle your mates, none of the super cool live lap updates, no trophies. And this is a game that retails at about a pound over the price of the more expensive minis. There’s an almost generational leap, somewhere, that’s not obvious to me and it’s not obvious to the gaming public.

For the sake of argument, here are the basics:

  • The first minis launched alongside the PSP go at the beginning of October 2009
  • They’re all bought digitally from the PlayStation Store
  • They work on PSP, PSP go, PS3 and PS Vita, in most cases
  • They range from less than a pound to nearer a fiver in cost
  • They have no PSN trophies (although some minis have their own similar trinkets)
  • They have no online functionality (multiplayer, leaderboards)
  • They have no ability to get DLC
  • They can be updated

A few developers have really focused on the platform. Halfbrick have four games, Beatshapers have five games out, Creat have five, EA have published Monopoly and Tetris, Laughing Jackal have ten out there, and Gameshastra have eleven. The idea was that developers could pass less stringent approval processes and get rather their more ‘indie’ titles onto a platform with buttons in the same way they could get them onto iOS.

For some, it’s fair to assume that there has been some success. But for the most part the games are lumped in with whatever else Sony has as part of their weekly Store updates, overshadowed by a pound off whichever AAA shooter a publisher wants to punt and sandwiched in between DLC and the usual raft of sixty avatars and XMB backgrounds. In short, the marketing of minis by Sony has been generally poor.

It’s not that there’s an issue with the quality of the games, either. Sure, some are rather throwaway but some – like the ones I listed recently – are brilliant games regardless of the price points. These aren’t developers short on talent: Velocity has been scoring 9s and 10s with abandon (and that includes from the likes of Edge magazine, notoriously hard to please) but even with such critical acclaim the guys at Futurlab are hardly driving around in supercars.

Reviews no longer translate automatically into the psyche of gamers – they just don’t, and probably never did. All you can hope for when writing a thousand words on a game is that you attempt to explain how it works and generally try to connect with those already interested. As the internet became more prevalent the desire for knowledge and information meant that services like YouTube became ever more important. I wouldn’t dream of buying a game based on a review – I take a sample of them, glance at Metacritic then pour over videos before even thinking about making a choice.

This may not surprise you, but it’s not rocket science to get a gameplay video up onto the PSN Store. In some territories this seems like some kind of bizarre, ridiculous suggestion – try browsing the SCEA Store for gameplay previews of minis games – it’s just not happening, and this means that many gamers simply won’t have any idea what the game is like (hell, some don’t even have screenshots) and that only means one thing: chances are they won’t buy it.

For minis devs, with limited budget for development let alone marketing and advertising, this means that games appear on the Store – often without even a few lines of text describing it from the PS Blog – and die without a trace. Velocity took Futurlab two years to develop – and whilst they were fortunately enough to be able to advantage of the PlayStation Plus promotion imagine seeing your game vanish after all that time if sales don’t perform.

The process has to be two way. Minis, like all games Sony sell on their Stores, make money for everyone. I don’t know what the cut is, of course, but why wouldn’t Sony push the platform harder? Why are the minis games constantly glossed over? The EU Blog at least used to highlight a few key titles at a time in round-up articles (which were great) but that seems to have ceased for the main part unless something is really getting pushed. Developers should be invited to comment, to raise awareness of their games, to engage with an info-hungry ready made readership like the Blogs enjoy.

There are sites dedicated to reviewing minis and they do them very well. PSP Minis is the key site, but I can only assume that the readership figures don’t compare with the likes of IGN or Eurogamer, two sites that seem to rarely cover minis unless the developer is persistent enough to continue pushing their new game to those responsible for editorial coverage. Awareness of the games need ramping up, and they need to treated with the same emphasis (or scaled appropriately) as everything else.

Some random thoughts:

  • Why don’t the various PS Blogs list what’s new each week in a permanent slot on the sites? The weekly main post disappears quick, and who’s going to trawl the Store looking for games without direction?
  • Why don’t we see more things like this?
  • Why don’t the various PS Blogs actually link out to the sites that do review the minis? The EU Blog continues to pass traffic to the Official PlayStation Magazine site alone, two sites that surely share an almost identical readership.
  • Why don’t the minis on the Store all have a video, screenshots, a list of review scores and quotes? Consider this an open invitation for any developer or publisher to take quotes from my reviews here on TSA – you shouldn’t need to ask.
  • A quick search on the EU Blog shows that – Velocity aside – there wasn’t a blog post dedicated to minis or a minis game (ignoring the Store updates) since the end of January.

But there are other factors here that could transform sales almost instantly. How about demos? Not demos that need already stretched developers to have to resubmit a cut-down version but a time-limited sample, just like XBLA Indie Games do. Let people download the game for nothing, play it for five minutes then ask for a couple of quid to keep playing? Simple to do at an OS level and won’t task the studios any more.

Can we attract more top level publishers and titles? EA are on there, Angry Birds is on there, but we want to see more.

What else can I direct at Sony? A greater emphasis on the official channels for those willing to work with you rather than splurge their time on iOS or elsewhere. A weekly or monthly round-up would suffice, I’m sure, and whilst I know that Call Of Duty makes infinitely more money for everyone I personally don’t care – and I’ll wager that the more people know about the better minis games the more developers will be interested, and it’ll grow from there.

And PlayStation Mobile bothers me. What’s it going to turn into? Will that suddenly feature online multiplayer and Trophies, leaving minis even further behind? Sony need to court the developers and come up with something that lets them get the most out of the PlayStation platforms without being hamstrung by the limitations set in place when the PSP hardware was the sole target of minis, which it no longer is.

Could minis feature Vita and PS3 specific elements? I know at least one developer has managed to get high res art out of their game when played on the console rather than portable, could this be replicated on Vita so games can run at 960×544? I’m sure that the online portions will forever remain off limits, but could trophies be activated on the machines that allow them? Questions that only constant pushing will see answered, and hopefully solutions will start to emerge.

And there’s the obvious one: a web store. Let us buy and download PSN games via a browser, away from our consoles (like you can with the Xbox 360) and we’ll be able to give links to products, publishers will be able to buy advertising with direct links rather than the vague “find us on PlayStation Store” and sites like ours will be able to point you in exactly the right direction when we see something cool.

That’s got to happen. All this has got to happen. Whether that’s tomorrow, next month or next generation I don’t know, but I do know that more and more people are starting to take notice right now. We’ve got plans here at TSA that are forming to assist where we can given our limited resources – but support needs to come from everywhere.

30 Comments

  1. Great article, and loads of good points.

    But hold the press. What mini is it that has higher than PSP level assets and resolution on PS3/Vita?

    • Hungry Giraffe.

      • Very interesting. I never knew that was even possible. I find it crazy that it’s not been done more, because playing minis on PS3 is often not particularly pretty.

      • Love that game, it should be Vita compatible by now :/

      • I’m sure LJ’s Ross mentioned writing up a blog post with details about this, but I’ve not seen anything.

      • Great article!

  2. Good read.

    I honestly had no idea what minis was or care for them til I started coming more often on this site & tbh if I never came in here minis would be another feature on the os store I would have ignored. But I think they do need to put trophies in minis that is a real appeal to gamers. Yes some minis like the impossible game have their own trophy rewards whatever but it’s not the same as that ping on the corner.

  3. Minis need promotion and the time limited demo is a great idea.Not fussed about trophies and leaderboards tho.

  4. What an amazing artile. Expressing clearly the well-known problem of the minis titles while pointing the finger to the right people so they can take the required actions.

    After being a plus member for about 2 years now, I find myself with DOZENS of minis, which I never played more than 2, because of the reasons pointed above.

    I’m hoping that with PS Vita I can play some of those titles, since I tend to care less about trophies and multiplyers on portable devices. (I have no idea why :) )

    Once again, great point of view.. thank you for putting things so clear.

    • Sorry about the mistakes above, I forgot to read it properly before posting :(

  5. In my opinion Playstation Minis will most likely be replaced by Playstation Mobile anyway. There doesn’t seem room (or any point) for both to exist.

    • Agreed, it seems a bit late to try and ‘upgrade’ minis when PSS is imminent and more likely something that Sony will want to push.
      Good article all the same, i have 30-odd bought minis and there are some gems so it’s nice to see an informative feature like this.

  6. i’m a big fan of the minis, i’ve got like 45 of them.
    so i’d love to see them get more of a push.

    it’d be great if they allowed the minis to access other features of the ps3 and vita where available, like the second stick or extra shoulder buttons, even the touchscreen on vita.
    that would make more difference to me than trophies or leaderboards., though i am sure there are a couple that already have online leaderboards.

  7. Couldn’t give a shit about DLC, or trophies. Or leaderboards. Or multiplayer.

    Demos would be good though

  8. How about a “Mini’s Monday”. A seperate update to the PSN on another weekday to the main update, with its own PS Blog post and a few days worth of downloading before all the big releases crowd them out.

    Whatever actually does happen it needs to be soon, because the Minis developers of today may well be the AAA developers in 5/10 years and if they’re given support today by Sony that’ll be remembered and everyone can benefit the rewards.
    Not all minis developers will prosper, but if just a few do, Sony win, Devs win, Gamers win……Life wins.

    • I like the Minis Monday idea. That could be cool.

  9. Trophies wouldn’t matter to me, but leaderboards and trials along with the ability to play them in native res on a ps3 or psv would. I guess DLC could be cool as well as long as it doesn’t turn into a micro-transaction thing.

  10. PS owners (wether this be PSP, Vita or PS3) buy more DLC than Xbox gamers and I know little about Wii’s online content but probably more than them also. We have seen rapid sales for games like Journey, Flow, Outland and The Walking Dead. The question is, why would Sony not incorporate the same methods used for the successful PSN games in Minis? Trophies, Online play, High level advertising and better Production Values? People don’t buy Minis because better stuff is on the store, simple. Consumers always want the best thing, we don’t want to feel short changed in anyway. I guarantee, Sony stick better advertising, trophies and multiplayer into half of these Minis and they will sell like gold dust.

Comments are now closed for this post.

Lost Password

Please enter your username or email address. You will receive a link to create a new password via email.

Sign Up