New Nintendo 3DS XL Review

So here we are, Nintendo’s newest console has finally arrived on our shores, promising their most refined handheld experience yet. Coming in both standard and XL forms, there are plenty of options available to potential buyers, with Majora’s Mask and Monster Hunter special XL editions, as well as an array of all-new interchangeable faceplates for the standard edition.

First impressions are certainly very strong, particularly of the pure white New 3DS with its Super Nintendo coloured buttons, and the burnished silver of the New 3DS XL Monster Hunter edition. The system itself seems up to Nintendo’s usually solid manufacturing standards, though perhaps the back panel feels a little weaker than before.


The New 3DS XL edition has definitely grown, though it’s only a few millimetres larger than the older version of the handheld. Both the Start and Select buttons have been moved to just beneath the four face buttons, leaving a much smaller Home button in the centre below the bottom touchscreen. Whatever the changes, all of the face buttons have a very satisfying click to them, and feel suitably responsive.


Whilst the analog-slider and the D-pad seem unchanged, we now have the crucial addition of the C-Stick on the right-hand side, perfect for games that required camera controls, without the need for the bulky Circle-Pad Pro add-on.

Interestingly when I first try to use it in Monster Hunter 4 Ultimate, I have to set the game to use the Circle-Pad Pro to recognise that I’m using it, though I assume that newer games made purely for the system, like the forthcoming Xenoblade Chronicles, will recognise it as standard. The nub feels solid, and is certainly a huge improvement over the touch-screen camera option found in Monster Hunter 4 Ultimate. Whether it’ll be as comfortable to use as the Circle-Pad Pro will likely come down to personal taste, and the size of your hands.

The system now also includes ZL and ZR buttons further along the spine of the handheld next to the L and R ones. They feel a little out of place where they are, requiring a shift of the hands to reach them, and certainly don’t sit within reach when I hold the system naturally. However, given how few 3DS games will likely use them it’s hardly a deal breaker.


The most obvious improvement in the new editions is to the 3D effect. Labelled as Super-Stable 3D, the system tracks your eye and head movement, adjusting the on-screen images accordingly. It can’t be understated just how much better the 3D display is, with jogs of the hand and turns of the head all compensated for by the console. Monster Hunter 4 Ultimate looks spectacular in 3D but on my older XL I’d had to turn the effect off the moment the action started as I would constantly move and lose the image. The new technology actually makes using the 3D a viable and welcome choice which I would argue was simply not the case with the original; turning the effect off now actually feels like you’re missing out. The new screens also seem clearer and sharper than in the older version.

The other headline feature is the improved chip-set within the handheld, giving more power to developers, and finally making the UI operate much more smoothly. Until Xenoblade Chronicles arrives we’re not going to be able to really see the true differences, but Nintendo have promised that a number of games will look better, and at the very least will load quicker. The enhanced chip-set will also speed up download times from the eShop and improve the battery life, both of which are welcome improvements.

The New 3DS family now also sport NFC technology meaning they can now communicate with Nintendo’s incredibly popular Amiibo toys. At the moment there are only a few games designed with this in mind, with the main one being Super Smash Bros though hopefully more developers will be creating content with it in mind.


Much has been made of Nintendo’s system transfer process for those upgrading and thankfully it’s all been drastically overblown. It is still years behind the simplicity of Sony and Microsoft’s digital accounts, but the process is relatively quick and you get to watch some adorable Pikmin move your data too. I do have to say that I still found it nerve-wracking, as the idea of trying to restore my digital purchases from Nintendo following some kind of failure doesn’t bear thinking about, and having to unscrew and tug away at the somewhat flexible back panel was worrying. Thankfully though it all went off without a hitch.

As a revamp there are some very attractive changes for both current and prospective 3DS owners, particularly in terms of the drastically improved 3D effect. However, the enhanced chip-set – as well as the accompanying exclusive games – look to divide the loyal user-base in a manner which Nintendo may come to regret. For those new to the system though, this is a fantastic and complete edition of the handheld which already sports an exceptionally strong library of games.



  1. I don’t get why they’ve added the extra shoulder buttons, Nintendo rarely use all the buttons anyway. It’s usually just a couple of the facebuttons and both Start and Select tend to be unmapped.

  2. when Xenoblade comes out i’m going to find it very hard to resist buying one of these.

    of course looking at the price will probably help with that. ^_^

  3. I’m tempted but not until more of the exclusive games come out. Are there any other exclusives announced besides Xenoblade?

    • Nope.

      I’m kinda annoyed by the Xenoblade port, because it ruins any chance of getting a Gamepad-compatible digital Wii version. That would’ve been SO awesome!

      • You never know – Nintendo’s plans have never made sense either way so don’t write it off yet!

      • Hopefully Nintendo will be able to add gamepad compatibility into any Wii game that supports the Classic Controller in a future update. Be it a digital or physical copy.

        It should just be a case of somehow running disc-based Wii titles through the same interpreter they’ve got for digital copies as an alternative to entering Wii-mode… But it makes too much sense to happen.

  4. One or two reviews I’ve read point out that the circle pad pro is preferable to the new nub when gaming as it seems more precise!
    Cracking update to the console though, especially with the loading times and 3D head tracking.

    • Well you could always use your Circle Pad when you know you are really going to need it, and yet not have to strap it on when it’s not that important you just can use the c-stick, it’s a win-win.

      • I haven’t had any problem with the use of the C-Stick, though I only based my test on Monster Hunter 4 Ultimate.

        Unfortunately, at least in the case of the New XL, the Circle Pad Pro no longer fits as the console is a few millimetres wider.

  5. Loving mine so far. The YXBA buttons have a better feel and response, the 3d tracking works brilliantly and the audio seems louder and clearer than my old 3dsxl. I am missing the longer L and R bumpers, but I’ll get use to that. The C-stick is ideal for Monster Hunter and games that require the circle pad pro.
    The only issue I have is with the system transfer as I have an older 3dsxl and 2ds. I transferred my data, eshop purchases from the 3dsxl to the new 3dsxl with no problems with the view of the kids upgrading their 2ds to the older 3dsxl, but you can’t carry out more than one system transfer to or from the system within 7 days!
    So my old 3dsxl has a weeks holiday now.

Comments are now closed for this post.