XI
you are not logged in
Feature

Matter Of Perspective: Killzone Shadow Fall

Between a Wall and a hard place.

Note: This article will contain story spoilers for Killzone Shadow Fall.

This isn’t the first time Killzone has featured in Matter Of Perspective, looking at the conflict between Vekta and Helghan, and focusing on the grey area presented when the two sides are compared. However, this fresh look at the latest entry to the game won’t really focus on that but instead the social impacts of the large wall built between the two cities.

Walls are designed to define perimeters, keep things in, and keep things out. We’re surrounded by walls constantly but they exist in the background and not really as part of our thoughts. However there are certain walls which have had a huge impact on the world, from the Great Wall Of China to the Berlin Wall.

It’s from the latter that the team at Guerrilla Games seemed to have gained their inspiration for the latest Killzone tale. The Berlin Wall was a physical divide that split the democratic West and the communist East for over forty years. On one side a society that was growing quickly while on the other side people lived in more impoverished conditions.

We see this same scenario play out as the Helghast inhabit half of Vekta, turning it into New Helghan after the original was decimated in the war. This mass exodus and resettlement raises a lot of issues that also find their roots in our own history.

The most prominent issue is the outright racism expressed by the higher-ups of both sides, though the most extreme seems to come from Thomas Sinclair who is the leader of the Vektan Security Forces. There are many speeches given by Sinclair but one which really stood out was where he repeated that the Helghast were monsters and didn’t belong on the planet.

It felt even more poignant considering the recent stories in the media about the lifts on immigration in the UK and other parts of Europe who, though not quite as extremely, tried to demonise those from other nations who would come here to work. An increased version of such hostility wouldn’t be far from the attitudes Vektans have towards the Helghast, who took half the planet as their own.

In the initial relocation the Helghast would be targeted by Vektans based on their race and would have been exiled if found on the wrong side of the Wall. However, as the decades pass some Helghast eventually do cross the Wall to live in Vektan society and start to integrate. It’s only briefly shown during the game, and that is when they are forced to return to New Helghan.

kzmop2

Imagine being one of those who is forced to cross back over the Wall into the squalor, losing your home, friends and possibly family based on biological heritage. Even worse is the reception you receive from those who share that heritage, and that’s before passing through the checkpoints.

Again this is only shown for a couple of minutes as you pass through a checkpoint too, and you hear the remarks of the Helghast soldiers such as being called traitor. As one of those people who tried to establish ties and breakdown barriers peacefully you now belong nowhere, demonised as a monster by the Vektans and an outsider by the Helghast.

You are now at the bottom of the food chain thrown into a Helghast prison camp with no chance of reprieve. There is no mercy here with the minimum of provisions set aside for you. It’s an issue which is barely delved into by the game but it is there when you are escaping from the camp – you come across a man who is looking for supplies for his daughter but becomes cornered. Two Helghast soldiers corner this man and start throwing petty charges at him, then appear to be ready to kill him. All hope is gone until a Vektan saves him, creating something that you cannot see: an idea that it doesn’t matter if someone is Vektan or Helghan, but only their actions.

kzmop

It’s a small piece that brings a bit of hope in a place full of despair. This despair, as shown by the people in the prison camps begging for death, also highlights another thing about the opposing societies. All of the rhetoric of hate and patriotism comes from those who lead the two nations, while those nearer the bottom have other things on their mind like the need to survive.

Again, this is inspired by the moments played in history from the concentration camps of Nazi Germany to the internment camps of the US where many millions were victims of the propaganda of the leaders. The Helghast prisoners represent those that did nothing wrong except be born as what they were in a place they became unwanted.

Killzone Shadow Fall’s own tale may follow the path of one Vektan soldier who comes to the realisation that things aren’t right, but the world that has been crafted offers a major critique of unquestioned nationalism and the way leaders will play on that by coupling it with an enemy that can be portrayed as wrong, highlighting the differences as evil.

It is even more poignant now as the rise of such nationalism spreads through sections of Europe and the UK again. The lesson Shadow Fall appears to want to show above all others is that we’re not so different, we have the same worries and hopes, and that this divide be it a wall or ideology can lead to horrible situations if not handled properly.

5 Comments
  1. Greg Turner
    Member
    Since: Feb 2009

    Great read.

    I’m a big fan of the Killzone series and I was really disappointed with how the cmapaign of Shadow Fall turned out. In my opinion they should’ve concentrated more on the aspects you mentioned above… the cold war, the inequality, immigration etc.

    Really feel like they wasted a fantastic setting/opportunity with the usual ‘save the world’ nonsense.

    Comment posted on 13/01/2014 at 14:06.
  2. Eldur
    Member
    Since: Nov 2012

    *SPOILERS*

    Interesting.

    I thought the subject matter was handled rather bluntly, as is typical for most video games dealing with sensitive or suggestive themes. The writing of Sinclair, especially, became ever more prone to bouts of almost panto-like vitriol, so clearly being the ‘bad guy’ that it was almost laughable. Guerrilla never bothered to explain what motivated his extremism, which is a particularly deplorable sin given that your player character has far more reason to be a committed Helgan-hater.

    There were some more delicate touches though. I thought the trip through the slums was nicely done (as Aran mentions), and I thought the vignette where the player’s asked to choose whether or not to give valuable Adrenaline to a dying Helgan was a thoughtful piece of scripting. Even better, there’s no reward for your compassion which makes your decision even more worthy.

    Any hint of thematic intelligence was squandered by the epilogue though. Echo’s banal act of revenge, whilst providing a form of cathartic justice for those that need that sort of thing, was, at best, totally contrary to the beleaguered pacifist rhetoric she’d been spouting for the entire campaign and, at worst, committed her race to another turn on the cycle of blood she’d been so keen to avoid in the first place.

    Comment posted on 13/01/2014 at 15:29.
    • Scythegpd
      Member
      Since: Jul 2010

      I didn’t consider Echo’s final act as purely revenge.
      Sinclair had got hold of “the weapon”, sure it was coded to vektan however he was clearly going to try recode it to helghast. And considering his actions during the game does anyone doubt for a minute he wouldn’t it let it “slip out”, by mistake of course. Especially considering his accumulated power base by the end of the game.
      Her actions IMO were just as driven by the desire to avoid biologically targeted extermination of all helghast than just base revenge.

      Comment posted on 13/01/2014 at 18:31.
      • Eldur
        Member
        Since: Nov 2012

        I disagree. Doesn’t killing Sinclair simply prove his point that the Helghast are hellbent on a war with Vetka? And wouldn’t it only encourage his inevitable successor that the bio-weapon is a viable, nay necessary weapon? It undermines all the quais-pacifist philosophy that she’d espoused throughout the campaign.

        Anyway, surely it would have been more in-keeping with her agenda to steal the bio-weapon and destroy it. After all, this is somebody with the skill and equipment to waltz into Vekta, bypass all of their security and then kill the head of their military… A simple snatch and grab must be a cakewalk by comparison!

        And as for Echo’s motivation during the epilogue, I think her final words (and indeed the final words of the game) are are pretty clear indication of why she’s there.

        Comment posted on 13/01/2014 at 19:22.
  3. Foxhound_Solid
    Is a smart cookie.
    Since: Dec 2009

    Great read. Great game too :-)

    Comment posted on 13/01/2014 at 18:55.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Latest Comments

TSA Meets

  • None today