XI
you are not logged in
Opinion

Project 5: Heavy Rain

The first five minutes, teeth and all.

What is Project 5?

Last week we picked up on a story from the latest copy of Edge magazine regarding THQ’s Danny Bilson, and how he didn’t complete Heavy Rain because he didn’t want to brush his teeth in a game, an opinion that split our readership.  In amongst the sadly rather barbed vitriol was a common thread: you can’t ascertain a game’s value from the opening section.

Or can you?  It takes 5 minutes and 20 seconds to get Ethan Mars out of bed and into the bathroom for a quick shower and that all important dentistic scrubbing – a period we’re happy enough to round down to five minutes for the purposes of this project, an experimental, retrospective look back at a few top tier games to see how their first few moments stand up.

But first, and rather obviously, Heavy Rain.

Like any other game in this series, we’re negating any time downloading patches or running installs, most of them easily outstay the five minute limit on their own: we’re also not counting any initial cutscenes, we’re purely looking at the 300 seconds after the player gains control for the first time.  And in Heavy Rain’s case, it’s not going to be nearly enough.


Heavy Rain's opening doesn't even begin to prepare you for the expansive plot ahead.
It’s an odd way to open a game, looking back.  A man, the wrong side of the uncanny valley and dressed only in tight black shorts, lays dozing on a bed, the usual clutter of on-screen health bars and score tallies nowhere to be seen.  In fact, the first thing you’re presented with is a white square and an arrow pointing up, with a brief note to say that you’re meant to reproduce this direction via the right analog stick.

Not only is this action entirely at odds with almost every other game you’ve ever played (the right stick is normally reserved for camera control, if used at all) but it’s a world away from the direct control third person games normally offer.  Still, obligingly, you obey the instruction, before being told to do it again, but slower, as Ethan Mars stirs from his slumber.

Once up, the controls disolve further into confusion.  The left stick ‘aims’ Mars, and R2 makes him walk forward, stilted and uneasy.  It’s not explained whether the left stick acts as a rotation device, or it’s a more ‘direct’ aim, but a few seconds of bumping into the bed and the glass door confirms it’s the latter.  So, maneuvering like a dozy tank, you head towards the door after being silently refused the chance to get any clothes from the wardrobe.

The bathroom’s across the hall, but a sudden camera change as you near the birdcage (after a brief pause to pick up a note and open the bedroom door) throws you a little.  Still, by this time you’ve mastered the walking – and although the protagonist never really moves with any conviction through the entire session – he at least manages to find his way along the landing.

The teeth brushing scene is an odd one.  Eager to use every aspect of the SIXAXIS, Mars’ simple act of cleaning is, apparently, best approximated by the player shaking the controller vigorously – first from side to side, then up and down, in an inexplicably awkward few seconds of tiring action.  Still, his teeth are shiny, and now it’s just a case of a brief glimpse of pubic hair and it’s into the shower.

Five minutes, 20 seconds.


Although the game's core controls remain the same right up until the end.
It’s an oddly prosaic experience.  You might be able to aim Mars at his next target, but you hardly have full control, the game’s ‘interactive fiction’ moniker a convenient shield for oddly frustrating mechanics.  And the areas you can explore aren’t consistent, and the rewards even less so.

As an introduction, five minutes clearly isn’t enough.  Once Ethan’s first chapter is properly underway, with the arrival of the family adding some much needed pacing, Heavy Rain’s direction kicks into gear – but this first section is underwhelming, there’s no mistaking that.

Can you judge Heavy Rain from the first five minutes?  No.  It’s not even a taster, the tiny morsel of the game offered up in such a short timeframe doesn’t even begin to scratch the surface.  It’s indicative in terms of character and aesthestics, but little else.

The same, as you’ll see, isn’t necessarily the case for other games…

Read more: # #
27 Comments
  1. Nauraph
    Member
    Since: Jan 2010

    Personally I can’t judge any game from it’s first five minutes. Except for some arcade like psn titles. But mostly I’d need at least 30 minutes of playtime to give my first opinion, gameplay wise.

    Comment posted on 14/03/2011 at 15:05.
  2. tonycawley
    Pint! Pint!
    Since: Feb 2009

    Great concept for a series of articles! When can we expect the next in the series?

    Comment posted on 14/03/2011 at 15:07.
    • Sympozium
      Member
      Since: Aug 2009

      haha yeah, its a good idea

      Comment posted on 14/03/2011 at 15:11.
    • deadwelsh
      Member
      Since: Jun 2009

      I think this a great idea, and will only re-enforce my original point being that Bilson judged this game too soon, as this particular article has confirmed.

      I am looking forward to some of the other games that will feature.

      Gran Turismo, GTA4, MGS4 & Uncharted2 are some of my suggestions.

      I will also be interested to see how something like LA Noire which looks like it will be amazing fair when put to this test.

      Being a lovefilm customer I can sometimes have a pretty throwaway attitude with some games so maybe this will make me re-visit some titles which I may have previously glossed over.

      Comment posted on 14/03/2011 at 18:09.
  3. tactical20
    Member
    Since: May 2010

    Would be better comparing Heavy Rain to the first 5 mins of a movie.

    Comment posted on 14/03/2011 at 15:07.
  4. Sympozium
    Member
    Since: Aug 2009

    Hm… I haven’t bought it yet but I wouldn’t become fed up of such a beginning to a game, wonder what the same guy would think of yakuza 3 at the beginning.

    Comment posted on 14/03/2011 at 15:10.
  5. BIGAL-1992
    Member
    Since: Jan 2009

    Hhhhmmmmmm…….An interesting read into that. Will we hear more about Project 5 in future posts?

    Comment posted on 14/03/2011 at 15:12.
  6. TURRICAN-808
    Member
    Since: Jan 2011

    A while ago I heard rumours of the nesxt game having a SCI-FI setting, which would be welcomed than the dreary settings of Heavy Rain.

    Comment posted on 14/03/2011 at 15:13.
  7. Kevling
    Member
    Since: Dec 2008

    Nice article Alex. Although rather than having the desired effect, it made me think of Lewis’s Heavy Rain ‘Abridged Too Far’
    http://www.thesixthaxis.com/2010/03/12/abridged-too-far-heavy-rain/
    “To continue as Ethan Mars: Stand up, spin around 3 times and then go to page 2″
    Genius.
    Back on topic though, I can see where the guy is coming from (it’s why I stopped playing The Sims), but I think Heavy Rain needs this gentle introduction into what would (for people who had missed out on Fahrenheit, i.e. nearly everyone) be a whole different way of playing a game. I’m sure it could have been made more interesting though ;)

    Comment posted on 14/03/2011 at 15:26.
  8. Rob92
    Member
    Since: Dec 2008

    The question I would ask to this guy is, why not? Its a whole game centered on brushing your teeth, but Quantic Dream were trying to make a game where you could believe the characters were real (whether that was achieved or not is debatable) and well sir, if you dont brush your teeth then your not a very clean person are you.

    I, for one, found the walking controls just awful. Simple push forward to walk forward would’ve sufficed. The game itself though was one of the best games I’ve played this gen, loved it.

    Comment posted on 14/03/2011 at 15:42.
  9. grogy86
    Member
    Since: Aug 2010

    How could anyone judge heavy rain on the first 5mins? The game is on of the best ive ever played. Maybe Danny Bilson should have played the demo which reflects what the majority of the game is like. The first fight scene with Shelby got my heart pumping

    Comment posted on 14/03/2011 at 15:49.
  10. teflon
    Community Team
    Since: May 2009

    Even your bog standard FPS takes more than 5 mins to get you through the tutorial.
    In fact, I’d go as far as saying that the entire first full length level is usually where the main tutorial happens. You get lesser enemies in easy to manage numbers, and the new game mechanics are explained.

    KZ3, the tutorial level lasts 5-10 mins, does a bit of scene setting, explains basic combat controls, then delivers the “twist”. Then you get to the first proper level, get a bit of exposition in a 4 min cutscene, then you have two or three minor battles where you learn about brutal melee, and picking up the BIG guns. In total, that’s 30 mins.

    Uncharted 2, you get the most basic of climbing tutorials in the first 5 mins, then exposition, then the first level, where you don’t even have a real gun! 30-45 minutes for the first level. In UC1, I think it was even longer to get to the end of the first real level…

    Those are action games, and they take 45 mins to ease you into the game? Why does Heavy Rain have to prove itself in 5 mins? It’s at least an hour before you’ve met all of the characters, and got the hang of the controls.

    Comment posted on 14/03/2011 at 15:53.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

12 hours ago
3

Latest Comments

TSA Meets

  • None today